Immovable - Best Black Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil

The products pretty good .It stays in the waterline also except a little bit it runs in the inside of your eyes. And the only other thing that I would like is for it to be in a color brown or a brown black. There products are all just black and there's a lot of people with blonde hair or red hair and different complexions that black it's just way too harsh on them. But it does stay in place pretty much.

It was easy to achieve a winged eyeliner look and worked well on lining my inner rims of my eyes. It lasted without smudging for about 8-9 hours which is great compared to other liners I have tried. At about the 9-10 hour mark a rubbed my eyes and a little came off, however, that is a long time to wear so I have no complaints. I would definitely recommend this if you need something that will not tug at your eyes, or if you have sensitive eyes, or if you want something easy to work with. Will be repurchasing!

I used this eyeliner in my waterline and it went on so smoothly. Before applying, I tried swatching it on my hand and it applies so effortlessly. Definitely recommend this!

I love this eyeliner!It glides on, is easy to apply and stays put!All that and a great price!I highly recommend and will definitely buy again!

The Immovable eyeliner that wont smudge OR budge!! Hmmm Claims its an all day wear, water proof, smudgeproof and budge free. Eyeliner pencil does have a sharpener on one end which is very helpful. I tested this thru tears, sweat, rain, shower and it did not move or smudge. I actually have a hard time with eyeliner staying in the waterline that wasnt the case with this one. This one applies smoothly stays in place. It is definitely my top favorites,

This eyeliner lives up to the name. When I buy a new liner I will always wear test on my hand to see how it lasts though the day. This one passed, needs a oil based makeup remover to take off. All in all it compares well to the sephora brand liner I use to buy.

This is shockingly good eyeliner. I have been using Avon for years (which I’m pretty sure is a pyramid scheme but I digress) and had been looking for so long for a good cruelty-free eyeliner. I bought a couple from Rite Aid (Maybelline etc) and they were awful. I have big eyes and I like to smudge eyeliner or do wings so I really needed something dark. This is black to a T! It glides really well and it definitely stays on all day. No eye irritation whatsoever! Sorry the picture is bad, I had just gotten out of the shower lol

I am SO happy with this eyeliner. It lasts me all day long and I wear it on my inner upper lash line mostly because I’ve never been able to wear eyeliner on my water line because my eyes water so much but this one stays on all day. Even if your eyes are watering, and it doesn’t smudge all over the place. So happy I tried this out because now I’m obsessed!

This is a very good eyeliner for the affordable price. I really recommend it

Very good eyeliner

I got this eyeliner to create cool looks for Halloween and omg I loved how easy it was to draw a skull on my face and it actually staid all night very impressed

I love this eyeliner and this company I've been using their makeup for years and never had a problem

Love the little sharpener it has its so helpful to get even thinner lines

This eyeliner is perfection, seriously

Perfect black color. Love it

Very good eyeliner. Affordable price

I can't believe how good this eyeliner is for the low price wow

Best black eyeliner ever

Good

Never tried an eyeliner that stays on my waterline for more than 2 hours

Loved it

Very good eyeliner

My new fav one

Me encanta lo económico que es y lo oscuro que marca. El delineado se mantiene todo el día

I think I found my new must eyeliner

You receive more than you expect for 10 dollars

Very good for the price

I love how this eyeliner stays on even after working out with all the sweat

My wings stay 12 hours wow

Who says you need to spend a lot of money for a good eyeliner? This is the best eyeliner for 10 dollars seriously

Best eyeliner ever!!! So happy with this purchase

Still smudge in the waterline but if I'm honest, all my eyeliners does

Satisfied! It does what it claims to

Amazing product!

Perfect to gift! My bff's birthday is coming and I know she'll love a box full Mia Adora's products

Love how creamy and smooth this formula is

Best eyeliner ever

This eyeliner is amazing it stays on all they IN MY WATERLINE I mean... HOW??? My skin is so oily and it's the first time an eyeliner stays there for more than 2 hours

Love the small sharpener it comes with, perfect to get even thinner lines

This is the first eyeliner that stays on my waterline for more than 1 hour. Actually I wore it last night and stayed there for at least 6 hours pretty amazing

Very good

I'm a mua with a Salon in california and I've been using this eyeliner for months already and my clients are so in love with it they say it says all day even in their waterline. I have the same results the few times I've used it so very very good Mia Adora

If you're looking for a very black eyeliner that stays all day this is your best option. Love it

Very good eyeliner I love how dark it is and how smooth it runs over my skin

So happy with my purchase thank you

Easy to apply and lasts all day even in the waterline. Highly recommended

My friend told me to get this pencil because it's so good. I must say I wasn't that sure because of the price and the unknown brand (at least unknown to me lol) but omg I'm impressed with this eyeliner. It's the first time an eyeliner stays on my waterline, seriously and the color is so dark AND IT COMES WITH A SHARPENER TO MAKE THE TIP EVEN THINER this is my new fav eyeliner for sure

If you have crying eyes like me because of allergies, this product is perfect for you. It's the first eyeliner that actually stays on my waterline

Amazing eyeliner

I can't ask for a better eyeliner at this price

Very good. Not perfect but for the price is the best one

Immovable eyeliner now I understand why they gave it this name it actually stays on all day even in the waterlin so impressive

I'm not a big fan of liquid eyeliners so I'm always searching for the perfect regular eyeliner pencil and I can say that this one is by far the best I've tried and the price is so affordable which is amazing

One of the best black eyeliners I've tried in my life. This company has very good products and support some charities with the incomes so you get an amazing product and help people. What could be better?

Love the sharpener it comes with and the eyeliner stays all day even in the waterline which is amazing actually

Very good eyeliner

Vi este delineador en instagram porque una MUA a la que sigo le encanta y decidí comprarlo también. WOW es increíble lo bien que trabaja este delineador. De verdad lo recomiendo

Love this retractable eyeliner. It comes with a sharpener that helps you get thiner lines

Very good eyeliner

Mia Adora, queen of eyeliners love them all

Very good name for this product. It's completely immovable

Very good eyeliner for the price

Would I purchase again? DEFINITELY! Loved this eyeliner

Best black eyeliner ever

Big fan of this brand!! Love the way they do the things, their products, their support to charities. I think these are the brands that worth to be following and purchasing from

This is the second time I purchase this eyeliner. Loved it so much. It's so easy to apply and it actually stays in my waterline which is pretty impressive

They nailed it with the name. It's completely immovable woe

Love the sharpener. Very helpful to get thiner lines

Seriously this is the best eyeliner I've ever tried

Best eyeliner ever

Very good eyeliner. It was a gift for my birthday and I'm never going back to a different eyeliner

Perfect for the waterline

I think this is the best eyeliner I've tried. Seriously. It's incredible how it stays in my waterline all day

This is the best eyeliner I have ever used. It is 100% waterproof. It is cry proof and smudge proof. Worn it at a funeral and it did not run even with hours of crying and wiping my eyes. It doesn't break in color either. It stays dark and solid throughout the whole tube. No worries about throwing away early, you can finish the whole tube.

It's the first time that an eyeliner stays all day in my waterline. I'M IMPRESSED

Deep black color and easy application. Like it

This is definitely the best eyeliner I've ever used ✌️

Love it comes with a sharpener to get even thinner lines

In love with this eyeliner

Loving my eyeliner so far ♥️ I can see they changed the box and now looks even better can't wait to get that new box on my next order

Very good eyeliner! It's very easy to apply actually and looks very very black

Great product!

perfect for waterline nd contacts

Love how black it is perfect for waterline

If you wear falsies or lash extensions this eyeliner is for you

My absolute favorite eyeliner. Love the sharpener. Definitely waterproof and smudge proof. After 14 hours still needed an oil based remover to get it off

If you're not a big fan of liquid eyeliners, this is the perfect eyeliner for you. Love how pigmented it is and very easy to apply. Perfect for waterline btw, this is very impressive

Loving this eyeliner so much! The sharpener is so useful

Love it! Very pigmented but weak, be careful not to press too hard

Love its smooth application and the very deep black color

Goes on smooth and lasts all day but don't press so hard or you'll break it

I'm not a big fan of liquid eyeliner so this one is a perfect match for me. Love that it comes with a sharpener

This is now my favorite eyeliner. It looks great! It is long lasting even on the waterline. Also, it is retractable so the tip won't break off, the top snaps back on as well so no mess in the makeup bag or purse. It does not itch or break me out which isn't always the case with other products. Fast delivery service. I'm already placing another order.

This eye liner is amazing. I have a HORRIBLE time finding eyeliner that stays all day through my eye rubbing, allergies, sweating, and well just getting irritated from the eye liner. This stuff has held up through it all. It doesn't irritate my eyes like 90% of the other stuff I have used. It is sooooooo easy to apply and I don't end up with tears running down my face just seconds after putting it on. The real and best test though, I went to a Babymetal concert(if you don't know them you are truly missing out) so you know I was jumping, screaming, head banging, the works cause well it is a metal concert. The concert was 2 hours long including Avatar another metal band, 2 hours of sweating and having g a good time. I get out to my car expecting this giant mess of a face and my eye liner was still in tack! We got to the hotel I was to tired to clean my face just fell right asleep and the next morning my eye liner was still there like I just did it... What is this wonderfulness?? How did they do it?? I am now a fan, my love almost as big as my love for metal concerts.

This is the BEST eyeliner I've ever used! I love to wear eyeliner on my upper and lower water line and it's hard to find eyeliner that goes on smoothly and dark without irritating. This one applies so smoothly and I love that it is "self sharpening"! Other eyeliners that aren't can scratch your eyes if you don't watch carefully when it gets dull. For those reviewers saying this eyeliner smudges, I think maybe it's more about the oil in your skin or makeup causing it to smudge. I don't get smudging at all. I use ELF eye concealer powder under my eyes and my eyelids and it keeps those areas oil free all day. This will be a regular purchase for me.

I wear contacts and my eyes water with the slightest hint of wind, so I have been looking for a waterproof eyeliner that won't irritate my eyes. I started using this liner two days ago and I am in love! Glides on smooth with great pigmentation....no skipping or pulling. Stayed on for 12 hrs with no smudging, even through sleeping on my commute. Decent price, I will definitely be ordering more.

The formula glides pretty well and the sharpener in the bottom is awesome. I usually use a department store brand cake that you wet and hand paint on. It’s not as black as I would like and often times take a couple of applications to get the right color but the color of this pencil is deep and I will admit it holds up way better than drugstore pencils.

Not perfect, still smears a little, but no way as much as other products I used. I figure this has to be the best there is, not counting permanent eyeliner tatoos.

This eyeliner lives up to the name. When I buy a new liner I will always wear test on my hand to see how it lasts though the day. This one passed, needs a oil based makeup remover to take off. All in all it compares well to the sephora brand liner I use to buy.

I bought this because i line my waterline and this claimed to work. To my surprise...it does a pretty good job! It isn't perfect but i don't get raccoon eyes anymore and only need to apply it once. Good product for the money!